POLL: Can Fake Rhino Horn Stop the Poaching of an Endangered Species?

POLL: Can Fake Rhino Horn Stop the Poaching of an Endangered Species?

  • 59
    Shares


Fake cell phone cases coming to a store near you? It may sound strange, but that’s what one San Francisco-based startup has in mind—and it thinks such products can save the animals.

The company, Pembient, plans to bioengineer fake horn that artists could carve into lifestyle items such as jewelry, libation cups, and chopsticks, according to CEO Matthew Markus. Then the merchandise will be sold in China and Vietnam, where demand for horn fuels rampant poaching in Africa.

Pembient hopes synthetic horn—priced at about one-eighth that of the reported $60,000-a-kilogram that genuine horn commands—will flood the market. Prices for the real thing would fall, goes the argument, curbing the economic incentive for poachers—and helping save rhinos in Africa.

POLL: Can Fake Rhino Horn Stop the Poaching of an Endangered Species?
Poachers shot this rhino and hacked off its horn. A U.S. company, Pembient, thinks its plan to bioengineer fake rhino horn will curb demand for wild rhino horn, which has increased in recent years. Brent Stirton, Getty Images

Poachers have targeted rhinos in recent years at unprecedented rates. Last year, they slaughtered a record 1,200 in South Africa—home to most of the world’s rhinos—and have wiped away an increasing number of them in the country each year since 2008. (That’s after a rumor that rhino horn had cured a Vietnamese politician’s cancer, and demand in the country skyrocketed.)

Pembient emerged on the startup scene in January, when biotech incubator IndieBio decided to fund the venture and offer it a spot in its inaugural class. By isolating the gene for rhino keratin, the chief ingredient in wild horn (and in human hair and fingernails), Pembient says it’s managed to 3-D print genetically identical knock offs.
grinding rhino horn for powder

A woman grinds rhino horn on a ceramic plate at her home in Hanoi, Vietnam. Many Vietnamese say rhino horn has medicinal value and can cure anything from hangovers to cancer. There’s no scientific basis for this belief. STR, AFP, Getty Images

At first the company planned to focus on selling synthetic rhino horn powder before offering larger products. Several companies were interested in buying the powder to mix with beer and skin cream, among other things. The items would have been marketed to East Asian consumers, who tout rhino horn as a status symbol and a sign of strength. Some mistakenly believe that it can heal everything from hangovers to cancer.

But many conservationists attacked Pembient’s idea, asserting that fake rhino horn won’t solve the poaching problem and could even make it worse. They say that rhino horn powder-infused products could open more markets for illicit horn. “These are entirely new uses of rhino horn that will reach an entirely new audience,” Cathy Dean, the international director of Save the Rhino, told World Finance in September.

For now, the company is shifting its emphasis away from synthetic powder because, as Markus says, “we’ve gotten a lot of pushback. The carving process and the durable goods market seems very interesting to us because it’s been around for such a long time and it’s something that people maybe understand a little bit better.” He also thinks that intact horn is “what the market really desires” because it’s the “ultimate marker of authenticity.”

A recent trip to Vietnam helped influence Markus’s decision to jump straight to “carvables,” the scraps of which he says he learned end up in the medicinal market anyway. In Vietnam, shops that cater to wealthy Chinese tourists have been found to sell rhino horn bangles.

The Backlash Continues

“I frankly don’t see that it’s any better, to be honest,” says Susie Watts, a consultant for WildAid and co-chair of the Species Survival Network Rhino Working Group, referring to Pembient’s move to put faux powder on the back burner. While she’s aware that people buy rhino horn jewelry, Watts has never heard of rhino horn cell phone cases and chopsticks.

But opposition to Pembient’s synthetic horn plans extends beyond the possible new market it could create. “There’s very little, if any, relief on wild populations when we see commercial farming develop or commercial trade of a protected species,” says Douglas Hendrie, manager of the and investigations unit for conservation group Education for Nature – Vietnam. “The wild trade continues right alongside.”

Hendrie points to China’s legal one time sale of 73 tons of ivory in 2008, which arguably fueled the current elephant poaching crisis. China’s legal tiger farms have also stoked demand for wild tiger parts, according to wildlife activists.

An eight-pound rhino horn like this one can fetch about $300,000 on the black market. Pembient plans to sell its synthetic rhino horn at an eighth of the price of genuine horn. It hopes to flood the market and lower the price for the real thing. Brent Stirton, Getty Images

Patrick Bergin, CEO of the African Wildlife Foundation, also believes that inserting fake horn into the market could counteract efforts to educate people about why they shouldn’t buy wild horn, a strategy most activists push as the best way to reduce demand.

“If you start to nuance that message with some rhino horn is good, some of it is bad, some of it is legal, some of it is illegal,” he says, “you lose people and lose the clarity of the message.”

There’s also concern that fake horn could increase the workload for law enforcement in countries already struggling to contain the illicit trade. According to Hendrie, Vietnam doesn’t have the enforcement capacity to regulate the black market along with the legal one.

As for the United States, the Fish and Wildlife Service, which enforces wildlife law, hasn’t taken a stance on Pembient’s venture. Spokesman Gavin Shire says the agency is “looking at this and the implications of it.” One consideration could be the Rhinoceros and Tiger Conservation Act of 1998, which bans the export of any substance intended for human consumption that’s labeled or advertised as containing “any substance derived” from a rhino.

Markus says he’s working with regulatory agencies to address any legal concerns. He expects he’ll have about a year to figure it out, while his team nails down the science for constructing faux horn that’s as carvable as real rhino horn. In the meantime, the CEO knows he’ll have to contend with more opposition.

This article was first published by National Geographic on 02 Dec 2015.


We invite you to share your opinion whether fake rhino horn can stop the poaching of an species? Please vote and leave your comments at the bottom of this page:

Can fake rhino horn can stop the poaching of an ?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thank you for voting.

 

Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter

 

 

Supertrooper

Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 59
    Shares


Facebook Comments

5
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
avatar
Pierre Gagnaux

I don't think that is a solution, for me it's better to send rhino horns made with cyanide or other chemicals agents to the buyers, then you can stop the trade by loss of buyers !

Michele Jankelow

Tragically I do not think so! The people who buy the horn want the real thing! Terribly sad!

Simon Tucker

It will be just as effective medicinally as the real thing

Cat Vincent

What aload of twadle. cow horn is 'carvable and there are many other alternatives. this chap just aims to make his fortune out of a world class super-tragedy.Obliterating the market for Rhino Horn completely is the only way. Selling fake stuff will only drive the value of the genuine article higher and higher.

Arlene Labbe

People using it are ignorant.