POLL: Should crocodile hunting be legalized in Australia?

  • 188

Two suspected crocodile attacks in the same north Queensland area within a day have prompted a bid by Katter’s Australian party to legalise of the protected predators.

Wildlife officers and police believe Warren Hughes, 35, may have been killed by a 4m-plus crocodile that later “charged” a police boat searching for the Cairns man’s body on Sunday night.

The body of Hughes, who went missing on Saturday while spearfishing alone 200m off Palmer Point, was recovered on Monday with injuries “consistent with a crocodile attack”, police said.

It followed the mauling of a teenager who tried to swim the Johnstone River in Innisfail on a “dare” before dawn on Sunday, as well as several attacks on dogs around Cairns at the weekend.

A lunges out of the water near Darwin. There are now 100,000 salties in the Northern Territory, up from 3,000 in 1971. Photograph: Alan Porritt/AAP

Matt Brien, the manager of northern wildlife operations at the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection, said wildlife officers would set out on Monday night to try to remove the crocodile suspected of attacking Hughes, with “lethal force” an option.

“The animal charged the [police] boat and behaved quite aggressively and it seemed to have something in its mouth, although it couldn’t be confirmed,” Brien said.

“But based on the behaviour of this animal and the location, and also in recovery of the body, it appears that this animal may be responsible for the death of this man.”

Shane Knuth, one of two Katter’s Australian party crossbench MPs in Queensland’s hung parliament, said the party would draft laws allowing a controlled cull of the reptiles, including bounties and Indigenous-run safari hunts.

The Palaszczuk government updated its crocodile management strategy last week after earlier surveys found most “croc country” residents did not support a cull. The plan dictates “minimal” intervention on crocodiles outside populated areas, although it allows for the removal of aggressive crocodiles from remote areas such as Palmer Point.

But Knuth said the updated plan did not go far enough.

“This is much more important than politics. This is about the risk factors,” Knuth said. “Once we were able to even fish beside our waterways, that is now a risk.

“So we really need to make a decision on whether we’re going to look after the interests and safety of people, or back the crocodiles.”

Brien said a comprehensive study to determine the size and spread of Queensland’s wild crocodile population should be completed before consideration of any cull.

“Any time you manage something, you need to know what you have, so it’s fundamental that a survey gets done to know what is actually going on,” he said.

The history of crocodile hunting showed that the idea of completely removing the threat was an illusion, he said.

“As far as the issue of , there’s obviously going to be constant debate. I think it’s important to remember that professional hunting happened many years ago and that was ineffective in removing the species.

“You can’t remove a species that is cryptic, that is wary, that can travel hundreds of kilometres over a few days.

Lee de Paauw is recovering after being mauled by a crocodile in the Johnstone River.

“These things can travel across the ocean to islands, they can travel to other countries. The idea that you can do any form of culling and be successful in removing the species is just a fallacy.”

Brien said there was a large crocodile population in the area where Hughes’s body was found and an “opportunistic” attack by an animal drawn by splashing in the water would not be unusual.

But the behaviour of the animal towards the search vessel on Sunday was “not consistent” with the wariness of most wild crocodiles and marked it as one that had previously attacked humans, he said.

Lee de Paauw, 18, is recovering from surgery to save his badly mauled arm after he was set upon by a crocodile early on Sunday, moments after boasting of being able to swim the Johnstone River in the dark.

De Paauw told Channel Nine he had been trying to convince an English woman he wanted to impress that tourists were more likely to get taken by crocodiles than Australians, and jumped into the river to prove his point.

He said he had drunk “about 10 cups of goon”, but managed to escape the crocodile by gouging its eye and made it back to the shore with “one floppy arm”. He had two broken bones in the arm and bite marks from the croc, he said.

De Paauw said he didn’t want the crocodile harmed, saying it should be released and he wanted it to have “a happy life”. He rejected any suggestion he had done anything wrong, saying: “Haters gonna hate.”

Brien said it was not correct to say the area was “infested” with crocodiles but that their numbers were “healthy” and people should expect to encounter them in north Queensland waterways, particularly at night.

Sergeant Doug Godden said investigations into Hughes’s death were continuing and a report was being prepared for the coroner.

John Kremastos, the mayor of Cassowary Coast, which includes Innisfail, said the attacks came in a river that used to be safe to swim in. But Kremastos said he did not believe a cull was necessary.

This article was first published by The Guardian on 20 Mar 2017.

We invite you to share your opinion whether crocodile hunting should be legalized in ? Please vote and leave your comments at the bottom of this page.

Should crocodile hunting be legalized in Australia?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thank you for voting.

Editorial Comment: The purpose of this poll is to highlight important wildlife conservation issues and to encourage discussion on ways to stop wildlife crime. By leaving a comment and sharing this post you can help to raise awareness. Thank you for your support.


Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter




Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 188

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
Karen Crawford

Crocodile should definitely not be hunted in Australia. Why should the crocs pay with their lives just because some dimwitted teenager swims in a river where there are known to be crocodiles.

Rikki Salty

No, last thing we want is shooters! Its humans who have moved onto the landscape, hunting should only be done for food, otherwise its murder!

Dori Martell

No infinity

Peter Thomas Ross

Maybe to keep the numbers down

Paula Watkins


Deborah Barclay

Vote no leave wildlife alone

Delores Decker


Sanjit Sinha


Ann Kavanagh

No, absolutely not. You are definitely more likely to be killed by a drunk driver, speeder or weirdo. Yet nobody ever seeks there cull !!

Judy Eva

Silly people should stop swimming and playing in area’s where they are quite aware that it is crocks domain. They have been there longer than people so leave them alone and quit poaching on their territory.

Judy Eva


Jaime Gocoyo Gonzales

If they wipe them away..what will their future generation look at a real live crocks? At a book? In the internet?crocks dont atta k people..people came in thier teritory! If they got killed its thier fault not the crocks! Theyre shouldnt be there in the first place! Theyve steped the line..

Rakesh Arya

We don’t have the right to kill a life, moreover …..where ever is life there is God

Sherry Champion

simple – NO – no animal should be hunted in Australia in the name of conservation or sport!!

Nanci Nydegger


Joyce Kolasa

no no no

Kelly Maria

just don’t swim in the water….is all simple.

Linda Krieg Martinez


Mark Taylor

no hunting at all anywhere on the planet only peados and retarded human excrement hunt

Tierra Chapman

So Australian wildlife should pay en masse for willful human dumbfuckery? No! If an individual crocodile attacks a boat or is on one’s property and acting aggressively toward a family member or a pet, then self defense is on the table. But culling, legal or otherwise solves nothing and is just a pathetic excuse for our vile species to have their version of fun at the expense of the wildlife. Our species is long, long overdue to join the 21st century with our thinking and our treatment of non-human beings, including keystone predators such as these crocs. Time for the… Read more »

Monika Fisher

Crocs are CARNIVORES – Chimpoids are HERBIVORES, which makes us a prey species. Get used to it and stop whining about the rules of Ecology !! You don’t want to be et by a Croc ? Fine – keep clear of THEIR habitat. If you’d remained in your OWN habitat, you’d have been quite safe – Crocs don’t climb trees all that often !! 😀

Andrei Hanches

Saltwater crocodiles in Australia,have been hunted for a long time,for their skin.But big predators,are in need here.The long extinct Australian predators such as megalania,are no more.Its much better to have gigantic saltwater crocs rather than feral cats and dogs.They are endemic to Australasia and need full time protection despite the human-croc conflict.