POLL: Should the trafficking of all wildlife be banned?

  • 1.1K

The “year of the ” dawned recently in China – and with it, a trendy new exotic pet. Pygmy marmosets are all the rage among China’s wealthy elite, who are forgoing legality and snapping up baby monkeys at around $4,500 (£3,200) each. The internet has exploded with photos of the so-called “thumb monkeys,” while conservationists and primate scientists are lamenting the situation.

Weighing in at just over 100 grams (equivalent to about 20 US nickels), pygmy marmosets (Cebuella pygmaea) are the world’s smallest monkeys.

They’re native to the rainforests of South America’s western Amazon Basin, where they live in small groups of around a dozen individuals.

They aren’t considered threatened because of their large range and relative prevalence, but they are in decline, according to the IUCN, primarily due to the pet trade.

Pygmy marmosets are being traded as trendy pets for about $4,500 each in China. Photograph: Bobby Yip/Reuters

In a study published late last year in The American Journal of Primatology, researchers estimated that hundreds of thousands of primates are trafficked every year in Peru alone. Pygmy marmosets were the second-most trafficked primate species (squirrel monkeys were the first), accounting for 13% of the primates the research team found for sale as pets and bushmeat at Peruvian markets.

From their findings, the researchers concluded that levels of primate trafficking in Peru are still on par with those before the country enacted a ban on primate exportation in the 1970s. They write that a lack of enforcement capacity is largely to blame.

“There was one big shipment of 155 [pygmy marmosets] confiscated in Lima in 2010, probably on the way out of the country,” said Noga Shanee, researcher with Neotropical Primate UK. “Very low intervention rates of the authorities mean that the great majority of these shipments pass without even being detected.” Shanee told Mongabay that this is the typical way these monkeys are smuggled, and that many die before even reaching the coast.

Not all of China’s “thumb monkeys” are imported, Shanee said, and China may have established domestic breeding stock. However, these marmosets also stand little chance of survival, as the people who buy them often do not have the ability or knowledge to adequately care for them.

“Wild animal species differ substantially from domesticated animals and have low adaptability to captivity,” said biologist Clifford Warwick in a previous interview with Mongabay. “Stress from handling, transporting, or confinement in cages can often lead to early mortalities. Moreover, insufficient diets or inadequate thermal and humidity regimes can also result in deaths. The industry accepts high mortality rates because animals are cheap to source and the industry is dependent on mass sales and annual turnover/attrition.”

An analysis conducted by Warwick and his colleagues found that around 70% of traded exotic animals die at the wholesaler.

Escalating the problem, Shanee said, is the plethora of “cute” photos shared on social media by those who buy illegal exotics. This, in turn, can encourage others to go out and purchase their own trendy animals boosting the market and, thus, increasing the trafficking of primates and other wildlife.

“People [in Peru] think that if it is ok for a Chinese or an American to have a monkey pet, why can they not get one in the local market?”

Shanee cautioned that news outlets are also making the situation worse. She referenced RPP Noticias, a widely read news agency in Peru, which published an article glamorizing pygmy marmosets as pets.

“These kinds of advertisements can really boost traffic here in Peru,” she said. “We managed to make them change the note in RPP a few hours later to a much less positive one, but who knows how much damage was already done?

isn’t new in China. The country also has big issues with the trafficking of illegally harvested animal parts – often from highly – for . And “thumb monkeys” aren’t the only popular exotic pets in China. Slow lorises are marketed as children’s pets (after their venomous teeth are removed), and sealed plastic pillows containing live turtles, fish, and amphibians are reportedly sold as trinkets.

Animal welfare advocates in the country are pushing for stronger animal protection laws that would prohibit such practices.

“If a national animal protection law was enacted in China, such acts of cruelty could be prevented, and those who persist in causing harm and suffering to animals within their care could be prosecuted,” David Neale, animal welfare director of Animals Asia, told CNN.


  • Shanee, N, Mendoza, A P, & Shanee, S (2015). Diagnostic overview of the in primates and law enforcement in Peru. American journal of primatology.

This article was first published by The guardian on 26 Feb 2016.

We invite you to share your opinion whether the trafficking of all wildlife should be banned? Please vote and leave your comments at the bottom of this page:

Should the trafficking of all wildlife be banned?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thank you for voting.


Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter




Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 1.1K

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
Violet M Hall

I believe that all creatures that God put here on earth deserves to live in their own habitat. Anyone that abuses the animals and hold them captive and abuse them over and over again needs to go jail for a long time. And the ones that are allowed to do big game hunting are just as guilty. All I can say is they are lucky I am not a judge for the animals as they would be all in jail and would need more jails to keep them. I hate abuse of any kind be it babies, children, elderly or… Read more »

Donna Tasaka Moore

Unless said animal is going to a sanctuary and not a zoo.

Christopher James Glisson

African wild life is dissapearing at an alarming rate, not only to poaching but also bloodstained Dollars promoting the hunting industry…..and everything is targetted, from monkey to elephant.
Stop now !…….these animals belong to Earth, not YOU !

Maureen Tomkinson

wildlife should be left where it belong, IN THE WILD,

Ber Gear

If the creatures don't have a purpose for being here–then why are they here??
What is a humans purpose for being here ??
That's not hard for me.
Why is it so hard for you ??
I've never killed another living thing, so why should you ?? What makes you think yourself so special ??
Maybe, someday, some other race will come here–and you will be their prey.
I look forward to that day.
I voted "YES"–END IT–NOW!!!!

Environmental journalism for Africa


Arlene Labbe


Anne Sahlstedt

Yes it should be banned

Tara Wikramanayake

All wild animals should be allowed to remain in their natural habitat.

Grace M Yoxon

It is also a huge problem with otters. Throughout Asia otters are being “harvested” in the hundreds as their fur demands a high price in the illegal wildlife trade. Young otters are taken from the wild as pets, but often die due to inadequate care. If they survive they may be kept until they are big enough to fetch a good price for the skin. Apart from in more arid provinces, China’s otter population used to be widespread but now they are found in only 15 of the 35 divisions and they are rare in 9 of these. In the… Read more »