POLL: Should the use of elephants for tourist entertainment be banned?

  • 874
    Shares


During the episode of “The Amazing Race” that aired on CBS April 24, contestants had to ride Asian elephants across a river in Laos to reach their next destination.

“The Elephant Conservation Centre is funded by ecotourism, providing a safe haven and breeding program to ensure the quality of life and survival of these gentle giants,” host Phil Keoghan tells the show’s nearly 5 million viewers at the beginning of this segment.

Photo credit: The Amazing Race/YouTube

In its 2017 report Taken for a Ride, the culmination of a two-year study of the welfare of elephants in Asia, World Animal Protection (WAP) does include the Elephant Conservation Centre on its list of the venues with the best conditions for these animals. However, the report notes that the center offers “no elephant rides.”

Many reviews on TripAdvisor, which in 2016 stopped booking tourist attractions that allow people to come into physical contact with captive wild animals, praise the Elephant Conservation Centre for not allowing visitors to ride the elephants.

So what’s going on in this episode of “The Amazing Race”?

Well, if you look at the blue shirts the elephant handlers are wearing as well as a map the show displays, you’ll see they say Elephant Village, not Elephant Conservation Centre, which is an entirely different venue.

Elephant Village does offer the elephant rides. It should be noted that, unlike the Elephant Conservation Centre, Elephant Village is not included in the WIP’s list of the most humane venues and it is not on TripAdvisor.

So not only is this popular show promoting elephant riding, it’s apparently deceiving its viewers into thinking these elephants live in a place where their quality of life is being ensured, as the show’s host claims.

“At a time when more and more travelers and tour operators are starting to question the ethics of riding elephants, as well as the methods used to train them, it is simply horrific and unacceptable that The Amazing Race decided to portray it in a fun and entertaining manner,” writes Wendy Marcus-Minovitz, of the nonprofit Elephant Guardians of Los Angeles, in the Care2 petition she started.

In the wild, of course, elephants don’t naturally let humans climb up and ride them. On “The Amazing Race”, contestants had to use voice commands to communicate with the elephants—like “sohng” to get them to lift their knees so the contestants could climb onto the back of their necks, and “map” for the elephants to sit down.

“There’s no whipping, there’s no hitting or kicking, it’s just voice commands,” says one of the contestants. How does he think the elephants learned those commands?

While some captive elephants are trained using positive reinforcement, it can be a brutal process for others. In some cases, trainers literally beat the elephants into submission.

Renowned elephant activist Lek Chailert told Care2′s Judy Molland that baby elephants taken away from their herds in some southeastern Asia countries have their spirits broken inside what’s called a “crush box,” a log cage in which they are beaten repeatedly.

The WIP report recommends that to improve the welfare of elephants in Asia, tourist demand should be channeled away from “the worst activities such as elephant shows and rides” and instead focus on humane alternatives.

How shameful that instead of taking this advice and raising the awareness of its millions of viewers, “The Amazing Race” chose to deceptively promote riding elephants. There’s absolutely nothing amazing about that.

Take Action

  • Please sign and share this petition by Elephant Guardians administrator Wendy Marcus-Minovitz telling the producers of “The Amazing Race” to apologize for promoting elephant rides and to let viewers know the truth about this activity.
  • Contact this episode’s sponsors, including Travelocity, Subaru, Apple and Johnson & Johnson, and tell them to pull their ads from this show.
  • Don’t watch “The Amazing Race” or other TV shows that promote the exploitation of animals in captivity.

This article was first published by Care2.com on 30 Apr 2019.


We invite you to share your opinion whether the use of elephants for tourist entertainment should be banned? Please vote and leave your comments at the bottom of this page.

Should the use of elephants for tourist entertainment be banned?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thank you for voting.


Editorial Comment: The purpose of this poll is to highlight important wildlife conservation issues and to encourage discussion on ways to stop wildlife crime. By leaving a comment and sharing this post you can help to raise awareness. Thank you for your support.


 

Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter

 

Supertrooper

Supertrooper

Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 874
    Shares


Facebook Comments

4
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
avatar
Caro
Caro

Im horrified, I pressed the wrong button…I pressed NO …PLEASE can you remove my vote…Of course, like every decent human being I abhor the disgusting practice of elephants being used for peoples entertainment, or as beasts of burden.

Karen Lyons Kalmenson

Elephants are far superior to humans. That some humans actually think these “rides” are acceptable further proves how pitiful a species we are.

Diane
Diane

It beggars belief that 3 voters voted “no”. They should hang their heads in shame, especially after reading the article where elephants – babies – are beaten into submission just so that they can become a ride in a money-making organisation. These elephants should be left with their mothers. Humans don’t need to ride elephants. This is appalling.