POLL: Should USDA slaughter Canada Geese to protect water quality?

  • 98

In a change of policy, the Ocean Pines Association decided the nonlethal approach to the Canadian geese problem wasn’t working.

As a result, 290 geese were humanely euthanized as part of the USDA’s wildlife damage management project last week.

Tanya Espinosa with the United States Department of Agriculture would not go into how the geese were euthanized but said it was in accordance ofAmerican Veterinary Medical Association standards. The Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Wildlife Services also helped with the removal.

Compared to domestic Canadian geese, resident return to the area from which they were hatched. Ocean Pines officials said the resident geese were creating unsafe water conditions in the community.

Canada geese were endangering water quality in the the community of Ocean Pines on ’s Eastern Shore.

Deterring geese failed

A plan was hatched in 2014 to deter the geese from settling near the Association’s ponds and roads.

But previous attempts to deter geese did not work, including not mowing the areas around the lakes and ponds as well as using a product called “Flight Control” to deter geese from residing in Ocean Pines, said Martin Clarke, a member of Ocean Pines Environment and Natural Assets Committee.

“This is what we should have done five years ago rather than the smoke and mirror stuff that didn’t work,” he said. “Ask anyone that deals with that stuff, it is what leads up to what you do before you kill them. It’s feel good stuff.”

The Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Wildlife Services has the authority to work with local organizations to conduct such a program to address mammal and bird species, including Canadian geese, the Ocean Pines Association said in a release, because of their impact on local water quality and, thus, human health and safety.

Geese versus water quality

The Ocean Pines Association Board of Directors in 2014 agreed to spend $6,500 to control the growing number of resident Canada geese with a variety of nonlethal methods. In 2018 the OPA contracted with the USDA to have most of the geese killed without explicitly informing residents in advance.

John Bailey, Ocean Pines general manager, said in a release that, because they try to be good stewards of the environment, it is “regretful” that action was needed to maintain the balance between two environmental issues— the geese versus the water quality.

Unfortunately, the statement said, the geese led to “unacceptable levels of feces in the water and recreation areas of the community.”

The actions taken by the Ocean Pines Association were in compliance with the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Wildlife Services, Bailey said, and they made that determination before their arrival.

The project developed from the association’s Environment and Natural Assets Advisory Committee, which is made up of the community.

The Environment and Natural Assets Advisory Committee chairman, Tom Janasek, did not return phone calls or emails for comment.

The project was approved as part of the budget for fiscal year 2018-2019, and geese were donated to the Maryland Food Bank.

This article was first published by eu.delmarvanow.com on 06 Jul 2018.

We invite you to share your opinion whether USDA should Canada Geese to protect water quality? Please vote and leave your comments at the bottom of this page.

Should USDA slaughter Canada Geese to protect water quality?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thank you for voting.

Editorial Comment: The purpose of this poll is to highlight important wildlife conservation issues and to encourage discussion on ways to stop . By leaving a comment and sharing this post you can help to raise awareness. Thank you for your support.


Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter



Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 98

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
Monika Klewe


Arlene Steinberg
Arlene Steinberg

As a waterfowl community liaison who advises places how to successfully manage goose populations, I am aghast at the complete lack of knowledge that this HOA employed. It is incomprehensible that this HOA and general manager did not reach out to humane wildlife organizations or Canada goose management companies that have put together highly effective non-lethal programs to deal with Canada geese. In fact, this HOA actually STOPPED doing anything at all, in effect, creating the problem. Killing will not solve it. Let’s call this for what is it – a slaughter of harmless, helpless, HEALTHY wildlife. Euthanization is the… Read more »

Jessie Attard
Jessie Attard

If you had to kill them, I hope you used their meat as food. It would be a huge shame to kill an animal for nothing.

Arlene Steinberg
Arlene Steinberg

Not only did this NOT need to be done, but no reputable food pantry ever takes goose meat from these birds because of the possible pesticides on the grass they eat – it s costs $10-$12 per carcass to test for toxins, and no food pantry will risk this on the poor, who already have compromised immune systems.
However, the food argument is strictly a ruse to make people feel better about the killing, as if there is something charitable about this. It is about as charitable as a murderer donating the organs of his victims to a transplant lab.


Christine Minatelli