Iceland’s fin whales are endangered. Stop this bloody cull

  • 55

Last night, Hvalur 8 and 9, two vessels owned by millionaire entrepreneur Kristjan Loftsson, left Reykjavik harbour in , bound on a north-westerly course for the open Atlantic. Hvalur 8 was last logged at 64 degrees latitude, 23 degrees longitude before it went out of range of commercially available data. Together with its sister ship, its mission is to resume the harpooning and killing of , the second largest animal (after the ) on Earth.

Whalers cut open a 35-tonne fin on the western coast of Iceland in 2009, before a two-year moratorium came into being. Photograph: Halldor Kolbeins/AFP/Getty Images

For two years Iceland’s fin whale hunt has been suspended – but only because the economic market for whale meat, Japan, was suffering the after-effects of its cataclysmic earthquake. In the terrible logistics of global economics, the whale meat market is open for business again – partly, it is claimed, to provide luxury dog food snacks.

Iceland has set itself a quota of 184 fin , potentially to be killed over the next few months. Thankfully, that is an optimistic target on the hunters’ part. But the resumption of this cull raises once again deep political issues. Ironically, many Icelanders oppose whaling on economic grounds – the trade is bad for tourism, they say, since the whale-watching boats, which also operate out of Reykjavik, may find themselves witnessing the slaughter of the that their passengers have paid to see.

Conversely, Icelandic whalers – who killed their first minke whales of the season last month – have protested against new regulations forbidding them from operating in waters visited by the whale-watch boats – on the grounds that these are also the most fertile waters for their hunts. Meanwhile, the Whale and Conservation charity claims that tourists are actually sustaining the whaling by eating whale meat in Icelandic restaurants, believing that they are taking part in an essential cultural expression of the island’s traditional diet.

This Alice-in-Wonderland situation is only exacerbated by Iceland’s current and pressing dilemma over whether it should join the EU – which would surely insist on new controls, if not a cessation, of whaling. However, strident noises made by the Obama administration in the US earlier this year – promising direct political action if the Icelandic fin-whale hunt went ahead – appears to have fizzled out.

Last night’s sailing ought to challenge all those imponderables with the visceral, imminent and present threat: of the death of endangered animals (as they are classified on the International Union for Conservation of Nature, IUCN, “red list”). Fin whales, despite their size, remain mysterious creatures. Even in the second decade of the 21st century, we do not know where they go to breed – although they are the loudest animals on Earth. A fin whale on one side of the Atlantic can be heard by another fin whale on the other side. Unfortunately, we don’t appear to be listening.

Until three years ago, we believed that fin whales lived to be less than 70 years old. But the necropsy of a stranded fin whale in Denmark – believed to be a juvenile – was found, in analysis, to be 140 years old. We know so little about these animals that whatever political, economical or environmental claims may or may not be made by humans in determining their fate, surely the basic fact of our own ignorance ought to count for something? Apparently not to Loftsson and his crew, currently sailing out into the Atlantic, bent on their bloody mission.

This article was written by Philip Hoare for the


Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 55

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
Anda V Zevedei

happy you are vegan 🙂 go ethical vegan and you will understand why this is soo wrong and unnecesary.

Anne Grice

Disgusting and sickening – we see the evidence time and time again! Pure ignorant barbarism!


Sadly there is no excuse for killing whales, you are not a poor country you can do better. I know I would never travel to any country that continues to kill whales. Try whales watching instead of whale killing.

Guðmundur Bjarni Jónasson
Guðmundur Bjarni Jónasson

iceland hunts 1 whale every 2 months and most of this text is a lie i am a vegan but i know this is a lie and no they don´t kill whales in front of tourist and no they are not going to stop because this is there favorite meat so don´t lie about them it´s not going to change anything