POLL: Should whales and dolphins be kept in captivity for our entertainment?

POLL: Should whales and dolphins be kept in captivity for our entertainment?

  • 145
    Shares


A documentary examining the treatment of killer whales in claims that the giant mammals that have delighted generations of children are being deeply traumatised by their conditions.

The movie, which is called Blackfish and will be released in July in the UK and the United States, focuses on an animal called Tilikum who has been involved in the death of three humans, including the killing of trainer Dawn Brancheau in 2010.

Dawn Brancheau with Nalani, one of several killer whales at SeaWorld in Florida, in March 2009.  Photograph: Barry Bland / Barcroft Media

Tilikum, who was born in the wild and caught off Iceland in 1983, is still a main attraction at SeaWorld in Orlando, Florida. He performs regularly in front of crowds, though his direct interaction with trainers is strictly controlled.

The movie argues that Tilikum – whose name means “friend” in the Native American Chinook language – has been mentally scarred by his experience of being captured while young and then subjected to rough training techniques in confined spaces. He was also bullied by other whales that he shared a tank with. The result, Blackfish suggests, is not the frolicking, happy, tame beast that SeaWorld presents to thrill millions of visitors each year, but an aggressive animal who is a danger to his trainers.

The film details the first death – in 1991 of young trainer Keltie Byrne in the now closed Canadian park Sealand of the Pacific – and then a second incident in 1999, in which a man who stayed behind at SeaWorld after it shut ended up dead in Tilikum’s tank after apparently sneaking into the water with him.

Finally, it examines Brancheau’s death, which played out in front of a crowd, many of whom did not fully understand what was going on as the experienced trainer was dragged under water and flung around the tank. Brancheau had been one of the best-known handlers at SeaWorld and was used in advertising posters for the theme park.

The movie, made by relatively inexperienced film-maker Gabriela Cowperthwaite, has already won rave reviews and prompted a surge of criticism of SeaWorld. “There are probably no words to assuage this damning indictment of the theme park’s role in the death of a whale trainer at SeaWorld Orlando, nor to convince anyone of the humaneness of keeping wild animals in captivity for human entertainment,” wrote film critic Carrie Seidman in Florida’s Sarasota Herald-Tribune.

Justin Chang, a reviewer for the film industry bible, Variety magazine, called the film a “compelling psychological profile” of Tilikum. “The impression the film leaves is of a deep-pocketed institution that, for all its claims of humane and professional treatment, tolerates practices that are fundamentally at odds with the animals’ wellbeing and refuses to accept any portion of responsibility,” Chang wrote.

Cowperthwaite interviewed former staff members at SeaWorld who expressed concerns and doubts about the concept of keeping the animals in captivity. The movie also uses disturbing footage of other incidents and “near misses” where killer whales have threatened or injured trainers. Many of those clips were filmed as “home videos” by park employees and Cowperthwaite was only able to obtain them because the government sued SeaWorld following Brancheau’s death and they became accessible to the public.

The director also worked closely with writer Tim Zimmermann, who in 2010 published an acclaimed article on Tilikum called “The killer in the pool” in Outside, an American lifestyle magazine. Zimmermann also speculated that captivity lay at the heart of why Tilikum ended up a killer. “Tilikum, before 26 years in marine parks . . . once knew what it was like to swim the ocean alongside his mother and family. And perhaps, just perhaps, that also explains why Dawn Brancheau died,” he wrote.

No one from SeaWorld responded to a request for comment from the Observer. Nor did the park provide anyone to appear on film in Cowperthwaite’s documentary. But SeaWorld has previously denied any examples of wrongdoing. In a statement the firm has said that many of the allegations in the movie are “unfounded”. It added: “The film fails to make the most important point about SeaWorld – the company is dedicated in every respect to the safety of our staff and the welfare of our animals.”

The film’s release comes at a sensitive moment for the theme park operator. SeaWorld is currently planning on floating on the New York Stock Exchange later this year in a move that will value the firm at around $2.5bn.

The giant corporation owns 11 theme parks and earned some $1.4bn in revenue last year from 24 million visitors. With such a major corporate development on the horizon – and with its attractions being so core to its identity – the company will be keen to avoid any bad publicity.

We invite you to vote FOR or AGAINST the keeping of whales and dolphins in captivity for our entertainment. Please vote and also leave your comments at the bottom of this page.

Should whales and dolphins be kept in captivity for our amusement?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Now that you’ve voted, please sign the petition:

Free Lolita, the Captive Orca Whale

Don’t delay! Do it today.

The editorial content of this article was written by Paul Harris for the Guardian.

Supertrooper

Supertrooper

Founder and Executive Editor

Share this post with your friends

  • 145
    Shares


Facebook Comments

18
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
avatar
Susan Coppinger

These intelligent sentient beings have never belonged in captivity. I wonder sometimes why anyone ever thought of doing such a horrible thing. I know it is for money. I believe it is a crime against G
od, nature and these beautiful living souls. They have such a free spirit that should never be messed with or tried to contain.

Tanja Frey
Tanja Frey

i so understand what your sayin but if i didnt go to the metro zoo every weekend growing up and my son went to zoo camp. My oma paid to the toronto zoo for 40 years but never went she loved animals. i hate it but i think we as humans are stupid we need to see it in our face. to care its sad but the TORONTOZOO IS AWESOME ,

Tanja Frey
Tanja Frey

its not all about money .man has killed almost every rhino

Tanja Frey
Tanja Frey

this is about saving and making the next generation fall in love with animals too. animal abuse is not ok MARINE LAND CANADA NEEDS TO GO as a canadian i loved it as a young girl didnt know what was going on.

Susan Cowling

All dolphins and whales should be free to live their lives in the ocean

Jen Lord

If you want to swim with dolphins go in the ocean,people post videos all the time paddle boarding off the coast in Cali. With them and whales and its free !!

Mcat Russell
Mcat Russell

Hmmm. There is a reason they’re called wild.They LIVE in the wild!

Heather Klase Rowland
Heather Klase Rowland

Since my original post on Nov 2013, I have seen more article and news about this and other zoos all with abuse issues. It's such a double edge sword. I understand wanting to preserve the spices from extinction but to what extent? And why does it justify making them perform? There should be strict guidelines on the enclosure that MUST be met prior to obtaing animals,much stricter inspections w/steeper fines. Still if you look back in history and humans, as long as there has been pets & animals…there has been death and abuse. As for Sea World…I too have shown… Read more »

Sam Williams

In a word, NO!

Brian Farrell
Brian Farrell

I can’t believe seaworld management and owners do this to the orca whales and call it entertainment sick bastards the lot of them money rules all .

Brian Farrell
Brian Farrell

how can anyone in all honesty say that keeping orca whales in captivity purely for the entertainment of pathetic humans . this practice must be stopped shut down any seaworld shows NOW.

MRS. TRISH GEIDEL
MRS. TRISH GEIDEL

NO WHALES, SHOULD BE KEPT IN CAPTIVITY, : IT’S CRUEL & DISGUSTINGLY INHUMANE !!! THEY LIVE IN FAMILY GROUPS, IN THE OCEAN ! RELEASE THEM ALL !!! STOP BEING SUCH, GREEDY, SELFISH, DESPICABLE HUMANS !!!

Bjorn Olesen
Bjorn Olesen

I feel 'focusing on wildlife' is changing to become an animal welfare blog asking leading poll questions where you know the answer with 100% certainty. There are much better forums for this, and in my view you should focus on wildlife and wildlife conservation as in the past.

Flora Pino García

Me parece inmoral la maldita costumbre de esclavizar a cualquier animal y someterle a los caprichos humanos, pero creo que debería ser además ilegal si los animales en cuestión están en peligro de extinción. Basta ya de torturar a los animales!

Cheryl Hughes

All animals were born to be free, they are not here for our entertainment !!

Heather Klase Rowland
Heather Klase Rowland

There is simply NO enclosure that is large enough or deep enough that could come any where close to replicating this incredibly large and intelligent animal. It's a extreme act of selfishness on behalf of HUMANS to subject any animal to such torture for profit and our entertainment. This issues will never stop being a major problem as long as there is a human interest in controlling such wild animals. Stop going to these parks and perhaps they will get the message.

Ann Breeden

They weren't meant for our entertainment.

Wai Ling  Liu

no captivity , free whales and dolphins is need , give freedom , love , respect and responsible for animals alive , in the captivity must death and has more diseases thank you ,